Refund basics

Can a Canadian Recover Tax Withheld on BetMGM Winnings?

Why a BetMGM or other U.S. sportsbook win can have tax withheld from a Canadian, and how Form 1040-NR and the treaty are used to claim it back.

Elegant poker room with polished wood and red felt tables, stacks of red and cream chips in focus
On this page
  1. Why a U.S. sportsbook win can have tax withheld
  2. Where you were standing when you placed the bet
  3. Form 1042-S, not Form W-2G
  4. How Form 1040-NR recovers the withheld tax
  5. Losing bets and the Canada-U.S. treaty
  6. What counts as a record of online bets
  7. What the CRA says about U.S. gambling winnings
  8. What sits outside the federal claim
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

You were in a U.S. state, you opened BetMGM or another U.S. sportsbook or online casino app, and your bet won. Then you noticed that part of the payout had gone to U.S. tax. The IRS looks at BetMGM winnings, tax withheld, Canadian residence and where you were standing when you placed the bet. It then treats the result much like a win paid at a casino cage. This article settles why the tax was taken and how a Canadian resident claims it back through Form 1040-NR and the Canada-U.S. tax treaty.

Why a U.S. sportsbook win can have tax withheld

Fountain pen on a plain cream notebook beside two stacks of red and cream chips on light linen

The starting point is how the IRS classifies the money. IRS Tax Topic 419, which covers gambling income, counts winnings from sports betting and online casino games as gambling income. A payout from a sportsbook app sits in the same category as a slot jackpot or a lottery prize. A win placed through a phone does not get separate treatment because it was digital. For U.S. tax purposes it is gambling income like any other.

The withholding comes from a separate rule about who receives the payment. The IRS Instructions for Forms W-2G and 5754 state that gambling winnings paid to a nonresident alien are generally subject to 30% withholding under sections 1441(a) and 1442(a) of the Internal Revenue Code. A Canadian resident who is not a U.S. citizen or U.S. resident for tax purposes is a nonresident alien under these rules. The payer withholds the tax at source, before the winnings reach the recipient.

The reason for collecting at source is practical. Many nonresidents never file a U.S. tax return, so the law has the payer take the tax up front. The 30% is a flat rate the rule applies to the winnings themselves. It is a collection method set by statute and does not reflect a review of anyone’s full tax position for the year. That position is worked out later, on a return, if one is filed.

This explains why tax can come off a U.S. sportsbook win without describing how any particular app handles its own payouts. The rule attaches to the type of income and the status of the person paid. For a broader look at why the rate is set where it is, see why U.S. casinos withhold 30 percent from Canadians.

Where you were standing when you placed the bet

This article is about bets placed while you were physically inside a U.S. state. That might be a weekend in New Jersey or Michigan with a sportsbook app open on your phone. For U.S. tax, the deciding fact is where the wager was made and under which state’s license. Where you live, where your bank is, and where you later withdrew the money do not change that. A bet placed on U.S. soil under a U.S. state license produces U.S.-source gambling income.

Some sportsbook brands run separate operations in the United States and in Canada, each under its own license. The app can look almost identical on both sides of the border, and your login may feel like one account. The tax treatment does not follow the logo. It follows the jurisdiction the bet was placed in. A wager made in Ontario on a Canadian-licensed platform is a Canadian transaction, even if the brand name is one you have also seen in a U.S. casino.

That second case is outside the U.S. refund process. It is a matter for Canadian rules and CRA guidance, covered later in this article and in more detail in Are U.S. Gambling Winnings Taxable in Canada?. A U.S. claim only addresses U.S. tax that was actually withheld. If you placed bets in both countries during the same year, each bet is sorted by where it was placed. Only the U.S. ones belong on a U.S. return.

The table below sets the two situations side by side. It shows which tax authority’s rules apply, what U.S. paperwork can be involved, and where any recovery would happen.

Question Bet placed while physically in a U.S. state Bet placed in Canada on a Canadian-licensed app
Whose tax rules apply U.S. federal rules administered by the IRS, because the winnings are U.S.-source income Canadian rules, with the CRA as the authority to consult
U.S. withholding Can apply. IRS instructions say gambling winnings paid to a nonresident alien are generally subject to 30% withholding Not part of the U.S. withholding system
Form 1042-S The annual form a U.S. payer uses to report a non-resident’s gambling winnings and any tax withheld Not issued, because no U.S. payment to a non-resident is being reported
Route to recover withheld tax A U.S. return, Form 1040-NR, filed with the IRS No U.S. return involved; any question goes to Canadian guidance

Form 1042-S, not Form W-2G

The IRS uses two different forms to report gambling winnings. Form W-2G is designed for U.S. persons. When the winner is a nonresident alien, the payer reports the winnings and the tax withheld on Form 1042-S instead. That form covers U.S.-source income paid to foreign persons and the tax taken at source. A Canadian who waits for a W-2G after a U.S. sportsbook win is usually waiting for the wrong document. The difference is set out in more detail in W-2G vs. 1042-S: which one did you get?

A 1042-S is not issued bet by bet. It is an annual form. The payer prepares one per recipient for each combination of income type and tax rate over the calendar year. Under the form’s instructions, it is furnished to the recipient by March 15 of the following year. A series of winning wagers placed through one payer in a single year can therefore show up on one form as a combined amount, with the combined tax withheld.

An app’s transaction history is not a 1042-S. Neither is a payout confirmation, a withdrawal record or an email saying tax was held back. Those records show what happened in your account. They can be useful later, especially as records of activity. They do not replace the form the payer files with the IRS, which is the document the withheld tax is matched against when a return is processed.

Form 1042-S comes in several copies, each meant for a different purpose. Copy B is for the recipient’s own records. Copy C is the copy that goes with the recipient’s U.S. tax return. When U.S. Tax Recovery prepares a Form 1040-NR, the figures on that copy are what connect the return to the tax already withheld. Why the form is worth holding on to is covered in Why You Should Keep Your 1042-S.

How Form 1040-NR recovers the withheld tax

A Canadian resident who is not in the business of gambling reports U.S. gambling winnings on Form 1040-NR, the federal return for non-residents. The winnings go on Schedule NEC, the part of the return for U.S. income that is not connected with a trade or business. That is the same category the withholding rules apply to. Form 1040-NR is where the tax already taken from a win is set against the tax the law actually imposes on that income for the year.

The tax withheld, as reported on Copy C of Form 1042-S, counts as a payment already made. The return then works out the tax owed on the winnings, after anything the treaty lets a Canadian resident subtract (the next section covers that). The withholding is credited against the tax owed. When more was withheld than is owed, the difference is an overpayment, and that gap is what can come back. The IRS reviews the return and decides the amount.

The IRS needs a taxpayer identification number on the return. A Canadian with no Social Security number uses an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, or ITIN. When the claim is a first one and no ITIN exists yet, the Form W-7 application goes in with the tax return instead of being sent on its own. The IRS processes the two together. More on that form is in what the W-7 form does for a refund claim.

U.S. Tax Recovery prepares and files these documents for its clients: the Form 1040-NR with its Schedule NEC, and the Form W-7 where one is needed. U.S. Tax Recovery is an IRS Certifying Acceptance Agent, listed on the IRS’s Acceptance Agents directory for Canada. That lets it certify identity documents for an ITIN application. It is a credential, and the company is not affiliated with the IRS. For a closer look at the return itself, see what Form 1040-NR is for Canadian winners.

Losing bets and the Canada-U.S. treaty

Article XXII(3) of the Canada-U.S. tax treaty deals with gambling losses directly. It lets a Canadian resident deduct losses from wagers placed in the United States when computing U.S. tax on U.S. gambling winnings, on the same basis a U.S. resident could. Without it, a non-resident is generally taxed on winning wagers with no offset for losing ones. For a Canadian who bet on a sportsbook app while physically in a U.S. state, losing bets placed there can be counted against the winning ones.

The deduction has a ceiling. Losses count only up to the amount of U.S.-source gambling winnings for the same year. If the losing bets add up to more than the winning ones, the extra is not deductible. A net gambling loss for the year produces no deduction against other income. The losses also have to be U.S.-source, so bets placed while in Canada on a Canadian-licensed app sit outside this calculation entirely.

U.S. law changed for tax years beginning after 2025. Under IRC 165(d) as amended, only 90% of wagering losses can be deducted. Because the treaty puts a Canadian resident on the same footing as a U.S. resident, that limit applies to the treaty deduction too. A year in which losing bets match winning bets still leaves part of the winnings taxable. For a 2026 or later tax year, losses cannot bring the tax to zero. Earlier tax years follow the rule in force for those years.

Which losses qualify and how they are reported on Form 1040-NR (Schedule NEC) is part of what U.S. Tax Recovery prepares and files for its clients. The IRS decides how the deduction is applied. The article What the Tax Treaty Says About Gambling Losses looks at the treaty wording in more detail.

What counts as a record of online bets

Older man with white hair writing in a plain notebook at a sunny casino-resort cafe table, chips beside him

The IRS sets out what it expects from anyone who deducts wagering losses. The taxpayer keeps an accurate diary or similar record of gambling activity, and backs it up with receipts, tickets or statements. A diary of this kind notes the date and type of each wager, where it was placed, and the amounts won and lost. The supporting papers are what tie those entries to real money moving in and out.

For in-person play, the usual support is a casino win-loss statement, drawn from the play tracked on a player’s card. It is common support, though it reflects only the play the casino recorded. The section on how a casino win-loss statement is used covers that document in more detail. An online sportsbook or casino account has its own equivalent. The wager and transaction history inside the account logs each bet, the stake, how it settled, and when funds were deposited or withdrawn.

That history fills the same role the win-loss statement fills at a casino. The operator generates it, it is dated, and it shows individual wagers rather than a single year-end total. Read alongside a personal record, it is the kind of statement the IRS standard refers to. A history that also shows the state where each bet was placed helps connect the losses to U.S.-source play, which is the only play the treaty deduction reaches.

A record is support, not a verdict. Deposits and withdrawals are not the same as wins and losses, and an account history can be incomplete if play ran across more than one app or account. The IRS decides whether the records presented are adequate and what follows from them. U.S. Tax Recovery prepares the Form 1040-NR from the records a client provides. It does not predict how the IRS will treat them.

What the CRA says about U.S. gambling winnings

The Canada Revenue Agency addresses this directly on its page titled Canadian residents going down south. Under its heading on gambling winnings, the page tells Canadian residents not to report U.S. gambling winnings on their Canadian return. It then says they cannot claim a foreign tax credit for U.S. tax withheld on those winnings. Both points matter for a sportsbook win placed while you were in a U.S. state. The winnings stay off your T1, and the 30% the operator withheld cannot be offset against Canadian tax.

That closes the Canadian side of the question. A foreign tax credit is how Canada normally accounts for tax another country has already taken. Without it, nothing on a Canadian return reaches the U.S. withholding. The only place that withholding can be addressed is a U.S. return filed with the IRS, which is the Form 1040-NR route described earlier. If you want the CRA position on its own, see Are U.S. Gambling Winnings Taxable in Canada?.

A bet placed while you were in Canada, on an app licensed in Canada, sits outside this picture. No U.S. withholding applies to it and no Form 1042-S is issued, so there is nothing for a U.S. return to recover. How that win is treated is a Canadian matter, and the CRA’s own guidance is where it is answered. U.S. Tax Recovery prepares U.S. returns. It does not advise on Canadian tax treatment of bets placed in Canada.

What sits outside the federal claim

The Canada-U.S. tax treaty lists the taxes it covers in Article II. On the U.S. side, that means federal income tax. State income taxes are outside it. The treaty’s loss deduction from the earlier section therefore works against the federal tax only. If a state also took tax from a win, that amount is a separate question under that state’s own rules. It does not ride along with the federal claim on Form 1040-NR. The background is in state tax withholding on casino winnings.

No single cutoff applies to every win. The time limits for a refund claim depend on the tax year the winnings fall in, and they are checked case by case. A win from an older year is not automatically out of reach. A recent one does not stay open indefinitely either. The tax year shown on the Form 1042-S is the starting point for that check, and U.S. Tax Recovery reviews it before preparing anything.

After a return is filed, the IRS sets the pace, and it varies from case to case. U.S. Tax Recovery publishes no timeline for it. A first claim that includes Form W-7 puts the ITIN application into the same review, which the IRS handles on its own schedule. U.S. Tax Recovery prepares and files the documents. It does not control what the IRS does with them, and it is not affiliated with the IRS.

IRS rules also decide how the money arrives. A refund can be deposited only into a U.S. bank account or through a foreign bank’s U.S. correspondent account. An ordinary Canadian account does not qualify on its own. Without an eligible account, the IRS mails a paper check to the address on the return. You can read more in whether the IRS can deposit a refund in a Canadian bank account.

Frequently Asked Questions

I’m Canadian and BetMGM took 30% off my winnings. Can I get any of it back?

A Canadian resident can often claim back some of it by filing a U.S. federal return, though the IRS decides the result. The 30% figure is the withholding rate U.S. law sets on gambling income paid to non-residents. That return, Form 1040-NR, reports the winnings and uses the Canada-U.S. treaty to deduct losses. U.S. Tax Recovery prepares and files it for clients.

Why would I get a 1042-S from BetMGM and not a W-2G?

Form W-2G is for U.S. persons, and a non-resident’s gambling winnings are reported on Form 1042-S instead. The 1042-S is an annual form. The payer issues one per recipient, income type and tax rate for the year, and furnishes it by March 15 of the following year. It shows the income paid and the tax withheld, which the IRS compares with the return.

Do my losing bets on the app count against my winnings?

For a Canadian resident, they can. The Canada-U.S. treaty lets a Canadian deduct U.S. gambling losses against U.S. gambling winnings on Form 1040-NR, up to the amount of the winnings. For tax years beginning after 2025, U.S. law allows only 90% of wagering losses as a deduction, so some tax can remain even when losses equal winnings. Most other non-residents generally cannot deduct losses.

Is my BetMGM account history enough to prove my losses?

It is useful support, but it may not be enough on its own. The IRS standard is an accurate diary or similar record of wins and losses, backed by receipts, tickets or statements. A sportsbook’s transaction history and annual statements often serve as that backup. Gaps in the record, such as deposits without matching wager details, can weaken a claim for losses.

Will a treaty claim also get back state tax that was withheld?

No, the treaty claim does not reach state tax. The Canada-U.S. treaty covers U.S. federal income tax only, so any state income tax withheld sits outside it. Form 1040-NR deals with the federal withholding. A state tax question depends on that state’s own rules and is looked at separately from the federal return that U.S. Tax Recovery prepares and files.

IRS Certifying Acceptance Agent badge
IRS Certifying Acceptance Agent Authorized to authenticate eligible identity documents for ITIN applications
Since 2001 Recovering U.S. tax for Canadians
Recovered $20M for our clients since 2024
Up front $0 We only get paid after you get paid

Let’s get it back.

Had tax withheld from your U.S. casino winnings? Let’s see what you can get back. We only get paid after you get paid.